Thursday, October 1, 2009

Fines For Flatulence?!

This week head coach of the Cleveland Browns Eric Mangini fined one of his players $1,701 dollars for neglecting to pay a hotel for a $3 bottle of water. Naturally, the player has filed a complaint for this incident, but to be honest, he has no idea what he's in store for. Mangini has a reputation for being strict with his players; he would fine Jets players for flatulence during team meetings (seriously). Personally, I'm a little torn between my emotions for these strict regulations. At first, I love the thought of a player getting an outrageous fee for neglecting to do something so simple as paying for a water bottle. (Thats only if the player didn't pay the bill consciously) Too many players today are becoming too showy, too egotistical, and too pompous. I don't think any professional sports player has any excuse not to live by the same rules we do, especially if they are making incredible amounts of money. Mangini's fines must be his way of keeping his players grounded, stopping their ego's before they're too inflated and reinforcing plain old fashioned good manners. But the part that tears me up about this is the state in which the Browns are in. Lets face it, they're HORRIBLE, and fining them for minuscule reasons is not going to make them any better. If anything, it's going to make the players more distraught and further divide them between the coaches and themselves. With this on top of the juggling act with his quarterbacks, what exactly is Mangini trying to do in Cleveland? Is he asking for the players and fans to throw him out? If he really wants this team to turn around he needs to stop sweating the small stuff, pay for the bottle of water that kept your player hydrated, and try to develop some kind of positive relationship with your players for a change.

4 comments:

  1. I liked this article I thought it was really interesting. I can't believe Magnini fined players for farting during team meetings, thats just ridiculous. Sometimes the players having a common hate for a coach on a team united them a little more because they finally have something that connects them all. It might just be the hate of their coach but it could make them better as a team. I agree with you about players becoming too egotistical, and I think the fine for a $3 water bottle is a little absurd, but if he is really trying to make his team better than he has a lot in store for him.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm a firm believer that there's no "cookie cutter" recipe for a good coach. What works for him and his team might be in that schools best interest. I know the record doesn't refect a good season. But a good team can't always be measured by stats. At the same time, I don't have to be a rocket scientist to realize the coach me bordering lunacy. I'm torn...

    ReplyDelete
  3. He is the coach and he can coach his team however he feels is right. If he feels that the team will be grounded if they pay the fine for not paying the 3$ bottle of water than thats how he is going to be. Sometimes the strictest coaches usually have the most respect. I'm not saying that I agree with the coaches decision is the best but what works for him is his coaching style.

    ReplyDelete
  4. haha i actually clicked this on your blog posts because of the title, made me laugh and i was like huh? Once i read it i understood what you were saying and what the coach is trying to do with his players. The coach feels like there is a sign of disrespect and granted, he might not need to be that harsh on his players, but it could be helping them. It is almost teaching his players to have respect for the game and to stop thinking about themselves, what about everyone else and the fans and the media which is watching them to screw up? Once they screw up it puts a bad rep on the rest of the team.

    ReplyDelete